Background checks are a standard part of the hiring process. Employers use them to verify identity, confirm qualifications, and maintain a safe and trustworthy workforce. But what exactly could cause a candidate to fail a background check—and potentially lose a job opportunity?
This blog explores the most common reasons individuals fail background screenings, outlines legal considerations, and offers practical tips for both employers and candidates to navigate the process effectively.
Several factors may trigger a failed background check. These include, but are not limited to:
A criminal record is one of the leading causes of failed background checks. Both violent and non-violent offenses can raise concerns, particularly for roles involving financial responsibility or public safety. The nature, severity, and recency of the offense are all taken into account.
Fabricating qualifications—like inflating job titles or listing degrees not earned—can lead to disqualification. Employers value honesty and may see these discrepancies as a breach of trust.
Bankruptcies, delinquent accounts, or excessive debt can negatively impact candidates seeking roles in finance, government, or positions involving fiduciary duties.
Drug testing is common in sectors where safety and focus are critical (e.g., healthcare, transportation). Even legal substances such as marijuana may disqualify a candidate if company policy prohibits their use.
For roles that require operating a vehicle, a poor driving record can be disqualifying.
References play a crucial role in verifying a candidate’s character and performance. Negative feedback from former colleagues or managers may cast doubt on your suitability for a role.
If prior employment, education, or credentials cannot be verified due to outdated contacts or discrepancies, it can lead to delays or disqualification.
Incorrect or inconsistent identification details (e.g., name, Social Security number) can complicate or delay a background check. Any attempt to use a false identity is considered fraud.
Being terminated for misconduct or poor performance can be a concern. However, candidates who demonstrate growth and accountability may still be considered.
Overstating your position or responsibilities can be seen as dishonest, particularly if it affects your qualifications for the role.
Public posts that are offensive, discriminatory, or unprofessional may affect how potential employers perceive a candidate.
Missing data due to unresponsive former employers or inaccessible records (especially overseas) can delay or prevent job offers.
Employers conducting background checks are required to follow legal guidelines to ensure a fair and non-discriminatory process.
Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), employers must obtain written consent from candidates before initiating a background check. If the results lead to a decision not to hire the candidate, the employer is required to issue a pre-adverse action notice along with a copy of the report. This step allows the candidate an opportunity to review the findings and dispute any inaccuracies. Following this, a final adverse action notice must be provided.
Additionally, many jurisdictions enforce “Ban-the-Box” laws, which restrict employers from asking about criminal history early in the hiring process, giving candidates a fair opportunity to be considered based on their qualifications.
Employers must also comply with guidance from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which prohibits discrimination based on race, gender, age, disability, and other protected characteristics during the hiring process.
A failed background check doesn’t have to be the end of your job search. With awareness, honesty, and preparation, you can overcome setbacks and improve your chances for future success.
Need a trusted partner for background screening?
SRA Screening offers compliant, reliable, and efficient background check services to help businesses make informed hiring decisions.
A “failed” background check indicates that the report revealed information that may disqualify a candidate from employment.
Common red flags include criminal history, poor credit, inconsistent employment history, failed drug tests, or unfavorable references.
Incomplete checks often result from delays in verification, missing data, or unresponsive references or institutions.
Employers can rescind a job offer if the background check uncovers disqualifying information.
It is possible, especially if previous employers disclose termination details during the employment verification process.
If drug testing is part of the background screening process, a failed test will typically be included in the report.
Start by requesting a copy of the background report. If you identify any inaccuracies, gather supporting documentation and submit a dispute to the reporting agency to correct the errors.
DISCLAIMER: This blog post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional before making any decisions.
The FCRA is enforced federally, but states may also enforce it and have their own consumer reporting laws. You may have additional rights under state law. For more information, contact your state or local consumer protection agency or your state attorney general.
When applying for a new job, your employment history is one of
Background checks are a standard part of the hiring process. Employers use
Navigating the world of pre-employment drug screening can be a complex and
Get updates, exclusive offers, and insights straight to your inbox.
